NCJ Number
66687
Journal
Justice System Journal Volume: 5 Issue: 2 Dated: (WINTER 1979) Pages: 197-203
Date Published
1979
Length
7 pages
Annotation
THIS STUDY EXAMINES THE EXTENT TO WHICH GREATER REPRESENTATION OF MINORITIES, WOMEN, AND OTHER GROUPS ON GRAND JURIES IS ASSOCIATED WITH A HIGH NO-BILL RATE FOR ROUTINE AND NONROUTINE TYPES OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITY.
Abstract
GRAND JURIES RETURN WELL IN EXCESS OF 90 PERCENT TRUE BILLS IN MOST JURISDICTIONS, WHILE PROCESSING A HEAVY CASELOAD. THIS SUGGESTS THAT GRAND JURIES ARE FREQUENTLY CHARACTERIZED LESS BY INDEPENDENCE THAN BY AGREEMENT. THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM'S EMPHASIS ON INFORMAL DECISION RULES FOR CERTAIN CATEGORIES OF CASES MINIMIZES INTERNAL DISCUSSION OR DISAGREEMENT AMONG JURORS AND ENABLES THE GRAND JURY TO PROCESS ENTIRE SETS OF CASES. THIS STUDY WAS CONDUCTED TO DETERMINE WHETHER THE GOAL OF 'EFFICIENCY' IN THE PROCESSING OF CASES WAS ADVERSELY AFFECTED BY THE MAINTENANCE OF DUE PROCESS PROTECTION FOR INDIVIDUALS ACCUSED OF A CRIME. IT FOCUSED ON THE UNIVERSE OF GRAND JURIES EMPANELED DURING MONDAY/WEDNESDAY SESSIONS IN HARRIS COUNTY, TEXAS, BETWEEN 1972 AND 1975. FOR EACH JURY, THE DEGREE OF REPRESENTATION FOR EACH CLASS (ETHNICITY, SEX, AND INCOME) WAS DETERMINED, AS WAS THE DISPOSITION OF CASES. FINDINGS INDICATE THAT REPRESENTATION OF MINORITIES AND LOW-INCOME INDIVIDUALS WAS RELATED TO NO-BILL PROPENSITY. TO THE EXTENT THAT THE GRAND JURY IS ECONOMICALLY AND RACIALLY REPRESENTATIVE OF THE COMMUNITY, IT MAY PRESENT AN OBSTACLE TO EFFICIENT PROCESSING OF THE MORE DRAMATIC AND CONTROVERSIAL CHARGES. THUS, GREATER REPRESENTATION OF MINORITIES AND LOW-INCOME GROUPS MAY SERVE TO HELP CHECK THE INFLUENCE OF THE PROSECUTOR BY FACILITATING DISCUSSION AND CONTROVERSY IN IMPORTANT CASES. A POSSIBLE BYPRODUCT OF THIS PROCESS IS A MORE INDEPENDENT REVIEW OF THE EVIDENCE. REFERENCES, A TABLE, AND FOOTNOTES ARE SUPPLIED. INFORMATION CONCERNING THE DEMOGRAPHIC COMPOSITION OF GRAND JURIES IS APPENDED. (MHP)