NCJ Number
200737
Date Published
October 2002
Length
40 pages
Annotation
This document discusses the challenges in providing forensic science services in Queensland (Australia).
Abstract
In 2001, an appeal against a rape conviction was upheld when fresh forensic evidence proved the appellant was not guilty of the crime. An investigation by the Crime and Misconduct Commission (CMC) found that there was no basis for criminal or disciplinary proceedings against any person. Although the Commission found no basis for any criminal or disciplinary proceedings, the investigation brought into focus the relationship between the Queensland Police Service (QPS) and Queensland Health’s forensic science services. Forensic science services present many important opportunities for shaping court outcomes. But the rapid development of these techniques and related services, as well as the rapid increase of demand, have outstripped the capacity of established systems for ensuring effective court outcomes. Concerns regarding the efficiency of forensic science services include police procedures for identifying, collecting, and passing on items for scientific examination; training for police investigators and senior crime staff; and the need to make better use of information technology for record keeping and information sharing. Recommendations have been developed for forensic science stakeholders. The first recommendation is that the QPS and the Queensland Health Scientific Services (QHSS) collaborate on the preparation of protocols and guidelines to ensure the most prompt, transparent, and effective means of relaying requests; and develop strategies that will make the number of items submitted for forensic testing more manageable. The second recommendation is that the QPS and QHSS collaborate on developing a coordinated and ongoing training program for key agencies involved in the delivery of forensic science services. The third recommendation is that an interagency working party be established to explore efficient work practices within and between all agencies involved in the delivery of forensic science services. 2 tables, 4 figures, 18 footnotes, 16 references