NCJ Number
65226
Journal
CRIME AND/ET JUSTICE Dated: (MAY 1977) Pages: 10-21
Date Published
1977
Length
12 pages
Annotation
LITERATURE ON THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ILLITERACY AND CRIME IS REVIEWED, WITH EMPHASIS ON THE INCIDENCE OF ILLITERACY AMONG OFFENDERS AND THE EVIDENCE FOR ASSUMING THAT READING DISABILITY CAUSES ANTISOCIAL BEHAVIOR.
Abstract
THE COMMONLY HELD VIEW IS THAT READING DISABIITY IN OTHERWISE ABLE STUDENTS IMPAIRS THEIR OVERALL LEARNING EXPERIENCES AND CAN LEAD TO EMOTIONAL MALADJUSTMENT AND TENDENCIES TOWARD DELINQUENCY. ESTIMATES OF THE INCIDENCE OF READING PROBLEMS AMONG JUVENILE AND ADULT OFFENDERS RANGE FROM 2.4 PERCENT TO 84 PERCENT. THESE ESTIMATES HAVE MAJOR SHORTCOMINGS, HOWEVER, INCLUDING DEFINITIONAL PROBLEMS, OPERATIONAL PROBLEMS, SAMPLING PROBLEMS, DESIGN PROBLEMS, AND RELIANCE ON RETROSPECTIVE INFORMATION. ALTHOUGH OTHER ELEMENTS OF THE POPULATION HAVE READING DISABILITIES, THE EVIDENCE SUGGESTS THAT A SUBSTANTIAL NUMBER OF OFFENDERS HAVE READING DISABILITIES. WHETHER THE READING DISABILITY IS A CAUSE OR A CORRELATE OF CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR IS NOT KNOWN, HOWEVER. THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN READING DISABILITY AND CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR HAS BEEN EXPLAINED IN TERMS OF SCHOOL-RELATED ADJUSTMENT PROBLEMS, REACTION TO FAILURE, FAMILY PSYCHOPATHOLOGY, PERSONAL PROBLEMS, AND SPECIFIC ORGANIC DEFICITS. IT IS CONCLUDED THAT ALTHOUGH AN ABUNDANCE OF ANECDOTAL, OBSERVATIONAL, CLINICAL, AND SURVEY-BASED DATA INDICATE A SUBSTANTIAL NUMBER OF OFFENDERS HAVE READING DISABILITIES, MAJOR GAPS IN KNOWLEDGE PREVENT ESTIMATING THE INCIDENCE OF THESE PROBLEMS OR DETERMINING WHETHER READING DISABILITY IS A CAUSE OR AN EFFECT OF CRIME. MORE CAREFULLY DESIGNED RESEARCH, USING MORE REPRESENTATIVE SAMPLES AND WELL-STANDARDIZED DIAGNOSTIC MEASURES, IS REQUIRED. LONGITUDINAL STUDIES BEGINNING WITH SCHOOL ENTRY AND STUDIES IDENTIFYING THE SPECIFIC NATURE OF OFFENDERS' READING DISABILITIES SHOULD BE GIVEN PRIORITY. HOWEVER, IF READING DISABILITY IS A CRIME CAUSE, IT IS PROBABLY NEITHER A NECESSARY NOR A SUFFICIENT ONE. FORCING A CHIILD TO READ WHO IS UNPREPARED OR UNABLE TO DO SO MAY SERVE ONLY TO HINDER PROSOCIAL ADAPTATION. TABLES AND REFERENCES ARE INCLUDED. (AUTHOR ABSTRACT MODIFIED CFW)