NCJ Number
139298
Journal
Polygraph Volume: 21 Issue: 3 Dated: (1992) Pages: 248-253
Date Published
1992
Length
6 pages
Annotation
This analysis of James Wygant's critique of the use of the polygraph discovery test as a method of controlling child molesters concludes that Wygant does not understand that pedophilia is a compulsive disorder involving potential lifelong recidivism and that the process of testing child molesters increases the likelihood of a treatment success and serves to protect society.
Abstract
Wygant stated that murderers are not forced to take polygraph tests and obtain treatment, but murderers generally only kill once in the heat of anger. The psychological damage that child molesters do and the compulsive nature of their order requires that sex offenders obtain help. Otherwise, they will continue to offend. It is important to recognize that the conditions that cause child sexual abuse persist, that approximately 25 percent of those abused become abusers themselves, and that treatment effectiveness is still uncertain. Therefore, no technique should be eliminated that could help reduce this problem. Wygant also criticizes the use of polygraphs for pre- employment testing. Although some of his criticisms have merit, he lacks information on this subject as well. 7 references