NCJ Number
75665
Journal
Mental Health Society Volume: 4 Issue: 1-2 Dated: (1977) Pages: 61-73
Date Published
1977
Length
513 pages
Annotation
The important role played by art expression as evidential visual material in court testimony supporting a plea of insanity is illustrated by description of a homicide case.
Abstract
From an initial spontaneous drawing on the back of a cigarette carton and through a series of subsequent drawings, a defendant, who shot and killed his victim before five witnesses, was granted a complete psychiatric examination on the findings of the drawing analysis. He was evaluated as paranoid schizophrenic and eventually was acquitted but found insane and committed to a State hospital for treatment. His drawings indicated his threatened sexual identity through a disturbed body image while his movement from reality to disintegration and back is evidenced in corresponding crystalline and fragmentary form productions. The case points out the significance of drawings for psychiatric examination and evidence where they are available. Five of the defendants' drawings are reproduced. A brief history of significant legal landmarks in determinations of criminal responsibility shows how modern views of legal insanity have evolved. Ten references are provided. (Author abstract modified)